It's possible that this is the easiest gift wrapping strategy ever.
You know, other than putting it in a bag, which I also use (especially for my pre-made art supply birthday bags from last year).
This year, my kindergartener had a triple birthday party, so each boy received a variation on a theme. A puzzle. A nice puzzle. In a tin, so it felt like it had some heft to it:)
I simply wrapped each up in brown craft paper. The same brown craft paper I used to cover my table with for an art-doodling dinner party.
Then I closed them up with washi tape and stickers from Trader Joe's. Use what you got, people.
I then "fancied them up", with some stamps, which I picked up at Target. I love stamping To and From on the gift paper, no need to make a card!